You’re Ignoring 95% of Your Buyers. Here’s How to Fix That.

Image source

There’s a loud obsession in the marketing landscape today. Marketers love hand-raisers, form fills and MQLs. But here’s the reality:

95% of your potential buyers aren’t ready to purchase today.

That’s right. If your marketing strategy is focused on chasing the 5% that are, you’re gambling growth potential on a shrinking pool of demand.

All too often, brands over-index on last-click metrics. Performance dashboards show green, but the sales pipeline dries up six months later. Leads don’t equate to revenue. 

Marketing leaders today aren’t here to stop at MQLs or fill CRM databases with contacts. They’re here to orchestrate the pipeline, drive revenue and build sustainable growth. The old model of lead gen and demand gen is carving the path to revenue generation.

Competitors who build awareness today dominate Day-1 Lists tomorrow.

The 95-5 Rule: A Growth Risk Hiding in Plain Sight

The LinkedIn B2B Institute evangelizes the 95-5 Rule, stating that 95% of your buyers aren’t in-market right now and only 5% are actively ready to buy.

Harvard Business Review outlines serious risks some advertisers and marketers underestimate when the 95% flip in-market:

  • 80 to 90% of buyers already have a self-researched shortlist 
  • 90% of buyers choose a vendor from their Day-1 shortlist. 


TrustRadius also provides the data on the realities behind B2B shortlists:

  • 78% of buyers creating shortlists report selecting products they’ve known of before their research. 
  • 86% of enterprise buyers do the same.

Brands that focus heavily on handraisers are already invisible when customers are ready to purchase.

Ty Heath of LinkedIn B2B Institute put it best during our Making the Case for the Marketing Budget fireside chat:

“If you're not on their mind, you're not on the list.”
Ty Heath
Director, LinkedIn B2B Institute

Marketers no longer have the luxury of dreaming of being on a shortlist with five to seven other companies. Those lists have been shortened to three to five companies, and sometimes just one. 

In this age of shrinking consideration sets and faster decision cycles, brand building is how companies pre-sell their product before sales gets involved. Say goodbye to seeing brand as a discretionary line item on the marketing budget. It’s now strategic infrastructure.

Brand as a Pipeline Strategy

For B2B marketing and beyond:

 brand = risk mitigation.

And the psychology behind B2B consumer behavior is simple:

  • Big decisions are inherently risky.
  • Purchases and investments can have positive and negative potential.  
  • People, especially marketing leaders, don’t bet their careers on unknown companies.
  • Trust is built before the form-fill.


These factors above are why being on the Day 1 List is mission-critical for brands. 

Here are the business impacts of being on the short list:

  • Higher win rates: Being on the shortlist means you’re in the running to win the deals. Your likelihood is multiplied because you’ve already established credibility.
  • Shorter sales cycles: Brands experience less friction among the buying committee because of trust, shrinking the sales cycle.
  • Better conversion rates: Kicking off warm relationships with buyers before they raise their hand contributes to conversion efficiency. 
  • Improved customer lifetime value: Branding doesn’t stop at the purchase. Many studies show that positive brand reputation directly correlates with customer lifetime value. 
  • Lower CAC and more predictable pipeline: Brand familiarity and trust built over time help fill the pipeline, which makes customer acquisition more efficient.


Nisrin Makki, Senior Digital Advertising Manager at Closed Loop, sums up why traditional channel thinking fails today:

“95% of buyers on LinkedIn aren’t in-market, and no number of demo ads will change that. Paid media’s job is to make sure they remember you so when they ARE in-market, they come to you first.”
Ty Heath
Director, LinkedIn B2B Institute

This is why strong brands invest in video, thought leadership and storytelling on LinkedIn, not just conversion ads. 

Funnel Stage ≠ Channel

For years, marketers have grouped channels by the funnel stage. But channel-first marketing is outdated. After all, channels don’t live in the funnel. Buyers do, and they move quite frequently.

The buyer journey is no longer linear. Customers don’t necessarily see an ad on LinkedIn, then engage in a search and subsequently fill out a form or make a purchase. They bounce around between touchpoints and self-educate, engaging with different content on the same channels for various reasons. 

Treating channels like buckets begets serving the wrong creative to the wrong buyer state. Imagine serving a demo ad to an audience out of the market or an awareness ad to a prospect actively evaluating you. The wrong goals, message, and time. That’s a waste of money and the chaos of fragmented paid media strategies. 

Channels can serve multiple purposes depending on audience targeting, KPIs and creative messaging. 

Full-funnel planning isn’t about buckets but the right balance and media mix:

  • Leverage all channels to reach out-of-market buyers with relevant messaging so they can learn about your brand before they need you.
  • Use the same channels to engage the 5% with relevant offers and proof once they’re ready to buy.

How to Protect Long-Term Growth Without Starving Current Pipeline

Investing in future buyers doesn’t mean neglecting the pipeline today. Marketers must move beyond the false “brand or performance” debate and instead engage in full-funnel media planning.

Full-funnel media planning balances spend so brands can create tomorrow’s demand while capturing today’s. It’s about balance.

How to Implement a Full-Funnel Strategy

1. Understand your audience

Start with an audience analysis to better understand your customer and identify areas of opportunity to connect. The more brands know about the customer, the easier it is to find connection points.

Use tools like Resonate & SparkToro to understand:

  • Media consumption habits: Where do they spend their time?
  • Psychographics and behaviors: What motivates them to act?
  • Barriers and objections: Why wouldn’t they convert?

2. Build the buyer journey

It’s critical to understand how buyers move from awareness to being in-market. As such, brands should map journeys so they know when to inspire, educate and convert customers.

3. Align creative with the funnel stage’s goal

Creative needs to match intent across the funnel. When it doesn’t, media and creative work against business goals.

4. Determine media investment

When determining your media mix:

  • Consider business goals and competitive landscape
  • Leverage historical performance and benchmark data to set expectations
  • Allocate budget for brand-building, demand capture and test your strategy to set the right mix.
5. Measure what matters

Full-funnel measurement considers other touchpoints and moves away from last-click metrics when measuring pipeline performance.

  • Consider Media Mix Modeling (MMM) and incrementality testing to optimize budget allocation for better ROI.
  • Closed Loop proprietary data solution Forager visualizes the impact of investment across ad platforms, backend data and CRM—driving clarity to make revenue-backed decisions.

The Takeaway for Marketing Leaders

Giving competitors market share is never a good idea, but it’s always a brilliant idea to build sustainable, long-term growth.

Full-funnel paid media is where brand and demand meet. Pivot your paid media strategy today to create the demand your future pipeline depends on. 

You May Also Like

Revenue Generation: The New CMO Mandate

Marketing leaders can no longer stop at MQLs. CMOs who align their teams around revenue, and run through the finish line, own the growth narrative, earn influence in the boardroom and build marketing engines that drive pipeline, not just leads.

Read More »