Article originally published by Search Engine Journal
Digital marketers can be our own worst enemies.
After years of touting that we can track everything and derive a precise ROAS from digital marketing, the expectation is that we can continue to do so. And while it is true that digital marketing offers far greater opportunities for uncovering the ROI of specific tactics and channels, it sometimes feels like this trackability has overshadowed the impact of softer, top-of-the-funnel KPIs.
Don’t get me wrong.
Advertisers should still use metrics like ROAS, ROI and LTV/CAC (lifetime value/customer acquisition cost) as north star metrics when distributing budget across channels and tactics. But building demand for tomorrow at the top of the funnel requires a different mindset which can make some marketers (and, let’s face it, their CFOs) uncomfortable.
The good news is that higher-funnel initiatives influence conversions down-funnel, and there are a variety of ways to measure it. In this article, you will learn impression-based KPIs you need to know as well as native and paid tools you can use to measure impression influence.
The buying experience has undergone rapid change over the last decade, and marketers and leadership have not caught up to buying behaviors.
At the root of the problem lies the difference between buyer behavior and attribution.
Meanwhile, company leadership often makes decisions on antiquated attribution models, like the last-click which ignores the very nature of buyer behavior.
So, how do you show the value of top-of-funnel advertising?
Conducting in-depth brand awareness studies is certainly an option for large advertisers.
But for smaller advertisers or those wanting to get a quick understanding of results, impression-based KPIs are a great way to optimize your top-of-funnel advertising.
If an impression is on the path to conversion, it has value. Consider your own experiences.
How many times have you seen an ad influence a future decision? You may not have clicked the ad.
It may have taken a day for you to act on it, but it clearly influenced your thinking. Those advertisers weren’t able to precisely quantify the value that impression/view had, but they knew enough to know it was valuable.
Quantifying what that value is can be tricky. But here are some key KPIs that should be included when evaluating the success of top-of-funnel advertising:
Top-of-funnel (TOF) initiatives drive brand awareness, which creates search demand. As a result, this is one of the best proxies of success for TOF initiatives
Brands that have more marketplace awareness who cleverly communicate their value proposition and differentiators see higher click-through rates. A pre-TOF initiative/post-TOF initiative analysis of CTR will provide insights into whether your efforts are paying off.
On YouTube and Display (using video in the responsive ad unit), an engaged view conversion is counted when at least 10 seconds of a skippable in-stream ad is watched (or the whole thing if shorter than 10 seconds).
Reach, frequency, and audience saturation can be a great KPI if you have well-defined audiences.
Examples of defined, high-value audiences include customer match lists, pixel-based retargeting lists, Custom audiences using the Searched on Google setting and account-based-marketing (ABM) audiences.
This is less valuable of a metric with ambiguous targeting, such as similar tos and lookalikes or when using “optimized” targeting.
On search, impression share can provide you audience saturation insights.
Attribution is hard. And messy.
No matter what a salesperson tells you, there is no one-size-fits-all solution for attribution — especially when you are trying to quantify impression-focused KPIs. Breathe easy though.
Here are five ways to measure impact using native tools:
While other tools exist, I can directly speak to the Google Marketing Platform products. Both Google Analytics and Google Analytics 360 (GA360) provide buyer journey reporting under Attribution > Conversions > Top Conversion Paths.
However, GA360 includes Google-based impression activity in these paths.
Another GMP product, Campaign Manager 360 (CM360), provides impression data beyond the Google ecosystem. Here, you can place impression tags on non-Google vendor URLs (eg. Twitter and Reddit) to get a more comprehensive look at how impressions influence the buying process.
This can be valuable information when media planning, because a TOF initiative may not get credit by solely examining click-based KPIs.
For example, we recently had a client observing poor lead performance on Reddit. We were considering cutting it, but we looked at our CM360-fueled Tableau dashboard and saw that Reddit was actually the first brand exposure (without click) 41 times.
This data showed that while on the surface, there was no conversion activity associated with the channel, it was introducing people to the brand, who were later clicking on another CM360-tagged link, then converting.
An impression to the right audience has value.
If you want to build a future-proof marketing program, demand must be generated through TOF initiatives that value non-click conversion points.
While it is hard to quantify sometimes, there are multiple indicators you can use to help you determine whether the channel or tactic is effective.
In summary, you should:
All the latest digital advertising tips and industry insights delivered to your inbox every quarter
Here at Closed Loop, we proudly cater to clients from all walks of creativity — whether you’ve got a full-fledged design army or still think ‘sans serif’ is a fancy French dessert. No judgment here! Here’s a handy guide to prepare you for your creative journey with our team.
Our work for Clover’s ‘On The Road’ is a SILVER award winner for AdAge’s Small Agency B2B Campaign of the Year. Learn more about the big win.
Effective RSA copy for search ads is critical for a successful search campaign. Learn how to write them to drive impact with these 10 steps and cheat sheet.